Find Key Cases
Browse key cases using the filter for either ‘Contravention type’ OR ‘Issue’. Alternatively, use the ‘Search…’ box to find cases through a custom query.
Cases on the site currently cover parking, bus lane, moving traffic and road user charging, including the London Congestion Charge and Clean Air Zones (outside London). More cases and contravention types will be added in due course.
Please note: All adjudicator decisions included on this website are in the public domain. While they have been curated together here for the convenience and interest of users, any information contained within the decisions remains the responsibility of the original adjudicating body. Any questions relating to the content of cases should also be directed to the adjudicating body.
Mr S – v – Birmingham City Council
(KW02338-2306)
Traffic Penalty Tribunal
Decision Date: 2023-06-21
Outcome: Dismissed
This case clarifies that a vehicle hire agreement must include a statement of liability for civil penalties in order for the liability for the penalty charge to be transferred from the owner to the hirer when using a vehicle in a Clean Air Zone, or otherwise.
Mr B – v – Sheffield City Council
(FD00130-2304)
Traffic Penalty Tribunal
Decision Date: 2023-06-07
Outcome: Dismissed
This case clarifies that yellow line restrictions apply to the carriageway, pavement and verge, and that an area the public can access can form part of the public highway, even if it is private land. Further, parking is not permitted adjacent to the restrictions marked by yellow lines in such areas. The cases also makes clear that the adjudicator cannot interfere in the authority’s exercise of discretion.
Mr K – v – Birmingham City Council
(KW01986-2305)
Traffic Penalty Tribunal
Decision Date: 2023-05-31
Outcome: Dismissed
This case highlights that proving an element of intention is not required under the fixed penalty scheme, and that an adjudicator cannot take mitigation into account.
Fife Council – v – Mrs M
2024UT04 Ref: UTS/AP/23/0032
Upper Tribunal for Scotland
Decision Date: 2023-05-29
Outcome: Judicial Review
This case underscores that the responsibility rests with the motorist to purchase parking time for the correct vehicle A contravention occurs when parking time purchased does not correctly identify the vehicle parked. This applies even when the incorrect registration mark was entered in error. That a payment was still made is not relevant. The payment must be made for the correct vehicle, identified by the vehicle registration mark provided by the motorist.
The Scottish Upper Tribunal decision is binding on the Scottish First Tier Tribunal for Scotland (General Regulatory Chamber) and is a persuasive decision in other UK jurisdictions.
Mr J – v – Reading Borough Council
(RG00089-2305)
Traffic Penalty Tribunal
Decision Date: 2023-05-28
Outcome: Dismissed
This case clarifies that private Hire Vehicles (PHVs) are not categorised as “taxis”, with being permitted vehicles and exempt from restrictions.
English (UK) 
Cymraeg